Tuesday, April 24, 2007

In search of heroes

So we have a young, former Private First Class who may or may not have "heroically" defended her last position behind the wheel of her truck. She may or may not have fired her weapon back at the enemy soldiers who had fairly much killed all of her friends. After all, she had serious leg, back, and spinal cord injuries suffered in the violence of the ambush against her convoy so she may or may not have had the ability to fire back.

In any event, she was heralded as a hero.

Then we have the NFL football player who gave up his millions to fight for what he thought was a great cause. On a ridge line in Afghanistan at dusk, some claim he was killed in a fratricide incident. Others claim he was killed by enemy fire. Whichever happened, it really doesn't matter because he's gone. The bullets cared not which weapon they came out of. Bullets are funny that way.

Continuing on, he was heralded as a hero as well.

Evidently, there is a large contingent of people who want both these stories exposed...in turn exposing a Pentagon tactic of creating heroes in the interest of national pride and unity. Of course, we wouldn't want that...not national pride and togetherness...how silly to think we need that.

The Tillman family is upset at the Army...well, upset is far too mild a word. They are furious at the Army for "fabricating a lie bordering upon fraud" with respect to their son Pat and his heroism or lack thereof. Interesting take on this one, huh?

IN YOUR LIFE - have you ever heard of the family of a deceased "hero" come out after the fact and say, "Well, Bill didn't actually save all those people in that burning building...he was just in there buying cocaine and he got trapped."

No, I don't think you have.

But if the family is angry because the talented one with all the money gave it up and went off to join the service - against their wishes - then perished...perhaps they would take issue with the story and everything surrounding it in order to deflect their awful truth - that they want some young soldier held accountable for their son's death. So maybe it was fratricide...and maybe fratricide has been around as long as mankind has warred...and maybe it is a tragic end to an enchanted life...but maybe, just maybe, he's getting more inappropriate press now because of his family than he ever got because of the military. My own growing despondency and the feeling that I need a shower every time I see another panel convening another inquiry (what is this...the 4th or 5th Pat Tillman inquiry?), has become so overwhelmingly sad for me I just had to write this clearly politically incorrect blog.

Pat Tillman died because he voluntarily joined the U.S. Army in a time of crisis. How he died is actually secondary to the simple fact that he died because he wore the uniform, a fact of life for those who do. He did not have to. He could have continued to play in the NFL and make his $5 Million a year.

But he chose not to play. And that - as tragic and sad as it may be - is that.

There have been and will continue to be, fratricides during the chaos of a firefight. We won't hear much about them though, because the family's of the fallen will allow the story to speak for itself - will not dispute it or the memory of their fallen loved one - and will bury their own personal hero with the honor and respect they deserve. And those families will act just like all the otherwise anonymous heroes who weren't good enough to play in the NFL and subsequently have the power to petition Congress as many times as needed to get the results they want.

Absolute power corrupts absolutely, and before Mom Tillman lobs another mortar round at the administration and the military, maybe...

Juuuuust maybe...

She should check herself out in the mirror.

R.I.P. Pat

4 comments:

Serena said...

I see what you're saying, and you raise some excellent points. There are those who seem to need an object of blame to focus on in order to find any "closure." I hate that word any more, but that's probably the word they're thinking. Fratricide happens; all soldiers know that. I'm sure that only rarely is it deliberate, but this is becoming increasingly a society in which there are "no accidents" and "somebody has to pay."

JL4 said...

Correct...my second point was that nearly 3,500 have sacrificed. The Tillman family has consistently stated they want the truth because they don't want Pat treated any differently than any other soldier...

But while they say those words, they persist in asking Congress and this country to do just that - treat him differently.

There are websites devoted to honoring the fallen, but you will not find Pat Tillman listed on any of them. Why? Because his family power-brokered to keep him off of those lists, the threat of litigation as their tool of choice. So, once again they say one thing and do another.

I wonder what Pat is thinking right now?

JL4 said...

Correction: Any governmental websites dedicated to listing the names of the deceased DO INDEED list Pat Tillman. It't the privately run sites like THE FINAL ROLL CALL that have been denied permission to list him.

leelee said...

I have to tell you...I am truly
disgusted that Pat Tillman and
Jessica Lynch were USED as
propaganda.
I can't imagine ONE American
who doesn't and didn't look at
either one of these VOLUNTEER
soldiers as heroes..SIMPLY for
volunteering their service to our
country. Don't be angry at the
families...they feel used as well.
They are proud of their children
and HOW they died or how they were injured is not what
it should have EVER been
about..WAR IS HELL..they knew that going in...their families knew that as well. The families have always considered their children heroes. Obviously this government didn't agree...the fact that thse fine Americans volunteered to serve was just not enough to be considered a hero...they had to make up stories of grandeur...they dishonored their fine service by lying about their circumstances..
I am NOT proud of Pat Tillman and Jessica Lynch being
USED as propaganda..that I find
vile and disgusting. I am proud of them "just" for serving. It IS enough and I am a grateful American.
RIP Pat. and Thank you Jessica
et al